| |
한탄강댐 건설반대 철원군대책위원회 |
[관련기사] |
| |
|
|
|
|
 이름: 강원일보
2008/6/4(수)
 20080604_강원일보_대운하_진짜_목적은_무엇인가.hwp (773KB, DN:125)
|
 [강원포럼] 대운하 진짜 목적은 무엇인가 [강원포럼] 대운하 진짜 목적은 무엇인가
( 2008-6-4 기사 )
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
이명박 대통령이 후보 시절 가장 크게 내세운 공약은 경부대운하다.
이것과 90년대 후반기 건설하려다 무산된 영월(동강)댐은 어떤 공통점이 있을까? 물을 다스리는 일, 대형 건설공사, 현대건설을 떠올릴 것이다.
그러나 원래 목적은 밝히지 않고 부수적인 것을 목적인 양 내세우는 모습이 공통점이라 본다.
무언가(물류비용절감, 용수공급능력 증대, 홍수피해 절감)를 해결하기 위한 수단으로 운하·댐이 필요한 것이지, 이들이 목적이 돼 물류, 관광, 홍수, 수질을 갖다 붙여서는 안 되는 것이다.
국책 사업은 하나의 큰 목적이 있고, 이 목적을 달성함으로써 얻어지는 부수적인 효과가 있다.
소양강댐은 수도권 물 공급이 주목적이지만 부수적으로 홍수조절, 전기생산, 관광효과도 조금 있다.
그런데 용수공급용댐이라고 주장하다가 갑자기 홍수조절용댐으로 바꿨다면 수상한 것이다.
강릉오봉댐이 그랬고, 한탄강댐이 그랬다.
초기 물이 부족해서 댐이 필요하다고 했다가 물 공급으로는 타당성이 없자 갑자기 주민의 생명과 재산을 보호하기 위해 홍수조절용으로 필요하다고 주장했다.
경부대운하를 보자.
추진 측의 첫 주목적은 물류비 절감이었다.
그렇다면 장래 발생할 물류량을 추정한 후 기존 시설로 소화할 수 있는 양은 제외하고 나머지를 고속도로 건설하여 운반할 것인가, 철도 또는 비행기로 운반할 것인가를 비교해야 한다.
그런데 물류비 절감이 말이 안 되니 내륙지방의 도시 개발과 관광을 위해서라고 말 바꾸기를 한다.
또 말이 안 되니 이제는 수질 개선을 위해 운하가 필요하다고 한다.
이것도 여의치 않자 홍수방지를 위해 하상정비를 하면 자동으로 운하가 만들어진다는 것이다.
더 기막힌 사실은 찬반측이 내놓은 경제성은 무려 1,700% 차이다.
경부대운하의 첫 발상지인 세종연구소는 100원을 투자하면 540원이 얻어지고, 대통령 측근들은 214원이 얻어지는 아주 경제성 있는 사업이라 주장했지만 반대하는 교수들은 28원에 불과하다는 주장을 하고 있다.
영월댐을 보자.
1996년 물 관련 우리나라 최상위 계획에서 수도권에 11억톤의 물이 부족하여 영월댐, 한탄강하을 당장 건설하지 않으면 목 마르며, 산업 시설이 마비된다는 주장으로 댐 건설을 시작했다.
그런데 2006년 수도권은 1회용 눈요기로 흘려 보낼 유지용수를 포함해서 연간 126억톤을 사용하는데, 평상시는 물이 충분하지만, 30년 가뭄이 발생하면 4,000만톤(0.3%)이 부족하다.
이는 수도권 사람들이 연간 한 번 정도 목욕하지 않으면 해결될 정도의 물 부족이라는 보고서를 내놨다.
한편 감사원에서는 2005년 수도권 물 시설 가동률은 55%일 정도로 시설 과잉 투자했다는 지적이며, 이는 물이 남는다는 얘기다.
따라서 영월댐 원래 목적은 수도권 물 부족이 아니다.
충주댐 자체의 홍수방어능력에 문제가 있는 위험한 댐을 만들었으므로 이를 지키기 위해 영월댐이 필요했던 것이다.
목적을 숨겼다가 무산돼 아쉬우니 수도권에 홍수 위기가 닥칠 때마다 “무산된 영월댐을 되살려야 한다”는 얘기가 전문가들 사이에서 종종 나오고 있다.
최근 한탄강댐 취소 소송 과정(2008년 6월27일 1심 선고일)에서 정부가 제공한 문건 중 깜짝 놀랄 사실 하나를 발견했다.
임하댐과 충주댐을 200년 홍수에 안전하다고 댐 규모를 정했는데, 지금 와서 보니 5∼10년에 겨우 안전하더라는 문건이다.
도로 측구도 20년 홍수에 안전한데, 댐이 10년에 겨우 안전하다니, 그래서 수자원공사가 관리하는 27개 댐 중 2개만 안전하고 모두 위험하여 소양강댐과 같이 여수로(방수로)를 확장하고 있는 것이다.
그러나 지구 온난화, 이상기후 등으로 몇 년 후 또 여수로를 확장해야 할 것이다.
좀 솔직하길 바란다.
목적을 숨겨두고 수단만을 계속 얘기해서는 안 된다.
최석범 한강수자원연구소장
 stories: -[07/01-01:58]-
forced: -[07/03-12:27]-
stories: -[07/04-16:18]-
stories: -[07/05-12:21]-
analrape: -[07/06-20:33]-
loans canada: Your website is very great. I enjoyed your website a lot. Thank you.
payday loans toronto online payday loans canada
faxless payday loans online payday loan
http://www.findpaydayloan.com/payday-loans-online.shtml http://www.findpaydayloan.com -[07/05-12:26]-
toronto payday loans: www.hantanlove.net is great! Planning a Summer Wedding Payday Loans Can Help You Overcome the Cash Crunch Given such a scenario payday loans seem to be the perfect solution loans toronto toronto loans loan toronto toronto loan payday loan toronto toronto payday loan payday loan toronto toronto payday loans payday loans toronto -[07/24-00:45]-
joissoveansal: http://thurrockneighbourhoodwatch.co.uk/index.php?action=profile;u=856 - cash advance cash advance
http://bodysport.hu/smf/index.php?action=profile;u=3082 - payday loans payday loans
http://mochileros.org/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=15460 - payday loans canada payday loans canada
http://www.babbaal.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=10071 - payday loans online payday loans online -[10/31-12:51]-
joissoveansal: http://www.school-grants-guide.org - school grants qvzssubu school grants trwszyjp organic mattress mqfsenep http://www.organicmattresshub.com - organic mattress ihbdojvx http://www.sampleresumeexample.org - sample resume elszcgmx sample resume qenbmsgd loans hamilton xnltbfna http://www.loanshamilton.com - loans hamilton uvenoywt http://www.weeklyspiritualreflections.com - spiritual gifts ammpnewg spiritual gifts ykaqvdpc football online ovemnpes http://www.finsfootball.com - football online tbmcewak http://www.onlineloanspayday.com - online loans payday ajfmiiqn online loans payday
-[12/26-11:43]-
joissoveansal: http://www.school-grants-guide.org - school grants nrczprht school grants ktpincqd organic mattress soppnkmc http://www.organicmattresshub.com - organic mattress vvivbwlt http://www.sampleresumeexample.org - sample resume dwtcaahi sample resume swopzmzp loans hamilton hmrrfvjc http://www.loanshamilton.com - loans hamilton hoptaqhf http://www.weeklyspiritualreflections.com - spiritual gifts vhzyagjx spiritual gifts qvdopplf football online ouqidiha http://www.finsfootball.com - football online iqvquieb http://www.onlineloanspayday.com - online loans payday iuzgwnxa online loans payday
-[12/27-10:28]-
caucceemn: Hello there Affiliate marketer! Opt to perhaps that I much like your world-wide-web site a lot more.
business credit card business credit card application business credit card using ein number only calendar template daily calendar template calendar template for kids car battery car battery replacements car battery light digital photo frame digital photo frame deals digital photo frame tool fitness gym pure fitness gym harbour fitness gym auckland green home prefab green homes fitness gym workouts hair removal electrolysis hair removal hair removal 77005 homemade pizza homemade pizza toppings homemade pizza for a crowd horse trailers shadow horse trailers horse trailers aluminum hybrid bike specialized hybrid bikes hybrid bike tire kevlar itunes itunes store itunes issues knee pain knee pain running knee pain 24 7 lavender plants buy lavender plants online are lavender plants poisonous to cats mini mac mini mac laptop apple mini mac money treev birthday money tree money tree nevada organic vegetable organic vegetable gardening organic vegetable wraps paintball gun tippmann paintball guns paintball gun co2 pontoon boats sweetwater pontoon boats pontoon boats in texas project management project management consulting project management zimbra ps3 games cheap ps3 games ps3 games for 2011 thyroid problem symptoms of thyroid problems thyroid problems nodules natural healing turnkey website turnkey website design turnkey website blog vitamin d vitamin d deficiency symptoms vitamin d yeast -[01/25-14:30]-
caucceemn: online faxless payday loans canada cash advance payday loans online payday loans ontario payday loans canadian payday loans no faxing payday loans payday loans hamilton area payday loans online payday loans canada same day payday loans payday loans personal loans payday loans online payday loans virginia payday loans payday loans for people on income support payday loans payday loans regulations saskatchewan payday loans payday loans kingston new york payday loans payday loans businesses payday loans 1 hour cash advance reviews payday loan cash advance letter sample format canadian payday loans cash advance bad credit score quick cash loans cash advance barrie ontario faxless payday loans cash advance 2010 online payday loans canada cash advance places work canadian payday loans how to get cash advance on mastercard payday loans ontario cash advance payments canadian payday loans cash advance greenwood indiana faxless payday loans cash advance lenders no teletrack online cash advance cash advance kansas city missouri bad credit loans apply for cash advance by phone canadian payday loans mastercard cash advance apr canada payday loans how to get cash advance on mastercard payday loan canada cash advance stores pittsburgh cash advance cash advance atm credit card online payday loans cash advance scarborough toronto pay day loans cash advance jobs in south carolina payday loans online cash advance kansas city mo cash advance canada cash advance belleville canadian payday loans national cash advance enfield no fax payday loan cash advance bad credit online faxless payday loans cash advance letter real estate payday loans no fax sacramento payday loan cash advance payday loans prince edward island cash advance usa locations online payday loan cash advance montreal cash advance cash advance phone number faxless payday loans national cash advance in canada online payday loans canada cash advance rate payday loans cash advance grand rapids michigan pay day loans cash advance philippines payday cash loan merchant cash advance uk online payday loans canada cash advance no bank account possible online payday loans cash advance loans in gardena ca cash advance cash advance 33186 faxless payday loans payday loans advance america payday loans legislation canada -[02/01-17:15]-
football: Hello Everyone! I like watching bbc football. I usually watch football online as I do not have PVR. How about you? -[02/21-08:17]-
mortgage broker vanc: Hello from http://mortgage-broker-vancouver.com>mortgage broker vancouver http://mortgage-broker-vancouver.com - mortgage broker vancouver -[02/21-08:33]-
payday loans calgary: Have you ever met with monetary emergency and need to have money inside a hurry? Don't appear additional as we at loansforcanada.netprovide the very best on the internet company to help you. With us you only need to meet several specifications to obtain the funds transferred into your account.* The citizen of Calgary, Canada* With minimal eighteen a long time of age* Employment proof* Existence of lively financial institution account in CalgaryAfter fulfilling these specifications, you may avail money within your financial institution account. The quantity might be utilized for tackling a variety of wants like clearing of health-related charges, financial debt consolidation installment, marriage ceremony expenditures, cellular telephone payments, vehicle restore, and so forth.The most effective component is the fact that citizens of Calgary who're marked with poor credit score score or don't have any collateral to have can avail payday loans. The quantity and repayment period of time is depended on the borrowers month to month revenue. The rate of interest charged is somewhat greater than other individual loans. So, persons throughout the Calgary take into account payday loans for Calgary to fulfill their urgencies which could not be waited till subsequent payday.With us at loansforcanada.internet you may avail payday loans Calgary for taking into consideration your urgent or unpredicted expenditures at aggressive charges when in contrast with marketplace quotes. See how to get http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vOiAR7BqGqQ>watch?v=vOiAR7BqGqQ watch?v=vOiAR7BqGqQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vOiAR7BqGqQ -[02/25-16:11]-
payday loans: Very very informative site!!!
http://forum.ciagaming.com/index.php?action=profile;u=5839 -[04/02-05:22]-
Home Security Monito: I like what you guys are up also. Such smart work and reporting! Carry on the excellent works guys I've incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it'll improve the value of my web site :)
Home Security Monitoring companies
-[04/15-12:32]-
sdfsdgfd: You certainly have some agreeable opinions and views. Your blog provides a fresh look at the subject.
-[04/19-03:16]-
Clinique Bonus Time: My partner and I stumbled over here by a different website and thought I might as well check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to checking out your web page again.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxFC_Fi2DFU -[05/04-10:15]-
affordable car insur: You can definitely see your expertise in the work you write. The world hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who aren't afraid to say how they believe. All the time go after your heart. low cost auto insurance utah -[05/17-09:57]-
blu electronic cigar: The other day, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!
the best electronic cigarette are the electronic cigarettes safe blu electronic cigarettes review green smoke the smokeless cigarette vapor cigarettes electronic cigarette price top electronic cigarette brands electric cigarette review green smoke review
blu electronic cigarette black blu electronic cigarette reviews
best electronic cigarette brands what is the best electric cigarette green smoke battery model njoy ecigarettes prado electronic cigarette where to buy at home sunburn treatment v2 cigs liquid what is the best vapor cigarette capo xhamster breast actives in malaysia free cosmetic bag patterns free makeup software free mens perfume samples -[06/07-12:10]-
bad credit loans tor: Hello there! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog. Is it hard to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thinking about making my own but I'm not sure where to begin. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? Many thanks
Bad Credit Loans Toronto Personal Loans for People with Bad Credit in Canada Loans People Bad Credit How to Get a Loan with Bad Credit Guaranteed Bad Credit Loans Get a Loan with Bad Credit Bad Credit Payday Loans Toronto Bad Credit Loans Personal Loans For People With Bad Credit Loans for Bad Credit Loan With Bad Credit Loan for Bad Credit Bad Credit Personal Loans Bad Credit Loans Ontario Bad Credit Loans Online Bad Credit Loans in Canada Bad Credit Loans Canada Bad Credit Loan Bad Credit Loans for People with Bad Credit in Canada Loans for People with Bad Credit Bad Credit Loans Payday Loans Ottawa Payday Loans in Canada Payday Loans Online Payday Loans in Vancouver Payday Loans Toronto Payday Loans Ontario Payday Loans Edmonton Payday Loans Canada Payday Loans Online Payday Loans Faxless Payday Loans Canada Canadian Payday Loans Payday Loans Calgary Online Payday Loans Canada Instant Payday Loans Faxless Payday Loans Canada Payday Loans Payday Loans Canada Payday Loans Online Payday Loans
-[06/09-12:27]-
compare auto insuran: I뭢 no longer certain the place you are getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or figuring out more. Thanks for wonderful information I used to be looking for this info for my mission.
auto insurance comparison quotes
auto insurance comparison quotes
compare auto insurance rates -[07/20-04:46]-
coupons: 에 대한 멋진 포스트 한탄강 사랑 :: [강원포럼] 대운하 진짜 목적은 무엇인가. 나는 매우 당신이 이야기를 쓰기 에 넣어 가지고 시간과 노력 에 감동 입니다. 난 당신에게 내 소셜 미디어 블로그에 링크를 제공할 것입니다. 모두 최고 !
http://couponcrasher.com/aeropostale/online-promotional-codes-for-aeropostale.jpg - online promotional codes for aeropostale http://couponcrasher.com/amazon/amazon-discount-coupons-kindle.jpg - amazon discount coupons kindle http://couponcrasher.com/amazon/free-shipping-coupons-for-amazon-online.jpg - free shipping coupons for amazon online http://couponcrasher.com/amazon/amazon-mp3-store-coupons.jpg - amazon mp3 store coupons
promo code aeropostale nov 2012 amazon coupon promotional codes shipping coupons amazoncom amazon music download coupons -[10/23-12:51]-
Tabatt11277
: gravare argint
-[11/12-19:21]-
Medak12185
: laser gravura
-[11/13-00:36]-
Hue
: latino fm
-[01/05-20:53]-
Prince
: radio fm online
-[01/06-03:31]-
Buy oem Softwar: nYaB1O Read, of course, far from my topic. But still, we can work together. How do you feel about trust management?!.... -[02/12-23:45]-
mr payday reviews: 블로그 소유자 님께 ! 내가 너무나도 유용한 정보를 제공해 주셔서 감사드립니다. 다시 한번 감사합니다.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=KnlBh4YZcxc http://youtube.com/watch?v=-aTNAyqaTss http://youtube.com/watch?v=pwhsTXnOYNs http://youtube.com/watch?v=QEv-HN7tsuw http://youtube.com/watch?v=q3SaQk-t77I http://youtube.com/watch?v=wTPBjsKVeJQ http://youtube.com/watch?v=tKjdBmLnpIA
Payday Loans Edmonton Ab Payday Loan Up To 1500 Payday Loan For Bad Credit History Payday Loans Windsor Canada Payday Loan Without Direct Deposit Payday Loans 24 Hours Payday Loans Canada Online Payday Loans 500 Bad Credit Payday Loans With No Credit Checks Or Faxing -[03/04-18:12]-
pradaja: LXJ10-29このシリーズのユニークなデザインは http://www.pradaja2012.com/
プラダ 財布 、 "チェルシー"、ゴアブーツの http://www.pradaja2012.com/
プラダ 財布 アウトレット 横に表示される新しい機能となっています。
http://www.timberlandjp2012.com/
ティンバーランド それはSaidogoaですが、あなたが装飾として靴紐を置くことができ、
http://www.timberlandjp2012.com/
ティンバーランド ブーツ あなたは2つの異なる表情を楽しむことができます。
http://www.ugja2012.com/アグ-ベイリーボタン-c-4.html
アグ ベイリーボタン あなたは味のブーツを変更し、その日のスタイルに適応することができ
http://www.ugja2012.com/アグ-ベイリーボタン-c-4.html
>アグ ベイリーボタン ブーツ 、私がコーディネートを幅広く好きです。
http://www.ugsjapan.com/ugg-アグ-クラシックショート-5825-c-3.html
アグ クラシックショート 疲労、抗疲労技術疲労ティンバーランドサポート快適な歩行を削減す
るためのシステムのインソールにも採用していますhttp://www.coach-jap.com/コーチ-ショルダー-バ
ッグ-c-3.html
。また、ウェットグリップラバーグリップhttp://www.coach-jap.com/コーチ-ショルダー-バッグ-c
-3.html
コーチ-ショルダー-バッグ-c-3.html"> coach人気ショルダーバッグ コーチショルダーバッグ 強
力な機能が備わっています他のデザインのバリエーションチャッカ、翼端、サイドジッパータイプが
表示されます。アパレルラインセット"エリート革アビントンを"ワックスコットン生地メーカー"英国
のブリティッシュミラレイン "の歴史は100年以上、それはまた、軍の外観として使用することができ
ます。lxj 10-29 -[10/30-21:46]-
|
|
